After NY’s mask fight, what’s to come for vaccine, testing mandates?
The chaotic fallout from a court battle over New York’s indoor mask mandate has fueled politically charged debate over the future of COVID-19 restrictions on daily life.
After a state judge struck down the mask mandate last week, schools and businesses scrambled to adjust policies before an appeals court issued a stay that kept the mandate in place during the appeals process.
Amid the legal drama, Gov. Kathy Hochul on Friday announced New York would be extending the mask mandate for businesses through Feb. 10, citing the lingering threat of outbreaks from the highly contagious omicron variant.
The saga also joined growing calls for Hochul’s administration to more clearly define how and when pandemic-related measures overall will be relaxed — or lifted entirely.
Beyond the mask mandate, similar policy clashes abound in coming months, spanning from mandatory COVID-19 testing for unvaccinated state workers — which could cost taxpayers up to $60 million — to potentially imposing a COVID-19 vaccine mandate for school-age children.
Hochul, however, has declined to set specific criteria for future pandemic policy, noting she would monitor trends in COVID-19 vaccinations, cases and hospitalizations. Her decisions, she said, would be based on the latest data and science.
“I don’t want to keep any requirements for safety in place a day longer than necessary, but I will not do it a day before we can do it safely,” she said last week.
Yet some advocates and health policy experts asserted New York’s current COVID-19 conditions, including declining cases and hospitalizations, warranted making changes to measures impacting everything from mask wearing to health care staffing.
“We have to be very careful and look at every mandate and every medical issue,” said Dr. Aaron Glatt, an Infectious Diseases Society of America expert. “But you can’t make policies that will be perfect, and everybody can’t stay in a bubble.”
Q&A on masks:Masks are (mostly) back in New York. What’s next for Gov. Kathy Hochul’s mandate?
More on mandate in court: New York’s mask mandate still alive; judge issues stay on decision throwing it out
NY’s COVID policy in 2022:Gov. Kathy Hochul’s ‘Winter Surge Plan 2.0’ to fight COVID in New York: 5 things to know
How mask and vaccine mandates evolved in NY
New York’s current debate over pandemic restrictions, in part, stemmed from state lawmakers voting last year to curtail the extraordinary governmental powers of the Executive Chamber.
That law – which effectively required legislative approval for a governor to impose new and significant pandemic-related restrictions – was approved in March. It came as scandals involving sexual harassment and COVID-19 deaths in nursing homes engulfed former Gov. Andrew Cuomo.
Cuomo resigned in August and was replaced by Hochul, whose first acts as governor included announcing a mask mandate for schools.
But the state law limiting Hochul’s emergency powers meant her mandate looked different from Cuomo’s previous one — he enacted the nation’s first mask mandate in April 2020 via an executive order.
Instead, Hochul requested that the state health commissioner and a key Department of…
Read More: After NY’s mask fight, what’s to come for vaccine, testing mandates?